“Ultimately, We Believe In A More Loving Church”
Essays, Featured — By John Wofford on October 6, 2009 at 12:00 am
As the debate over LGBT rights rages on, rising statistical trends show growing support for the gay community in the church. At the forefront of this movement is the Gay Christian Network, a non-profit organization that has worked with the likes of Tony and Peggy Campolo and Canadian religious program New Directions, in an effort to engage the discussion about the scientific and spiritual implications of sexuality. John Wofford recently held a discussion with GCN founder Justin Lee, and Office Manager/Donor Relations Specialist Nate Krogh, on religious politics, civil rights, and common ground between persons of faith.
—
JW: The Gay Christian Network celebrated its eighth anniversary recently. How did the Network come about? Where did the vision come from?
Justin Lee: It really has to do with my background. I grew up conservative, Evangelical—Southern Baptist, actually. I had nothing positive to say about gay people. I certainly didn’t think my life had anything to do with them. I believed what I was taught in my church, which was that homosexuality was a sin, being gay was a choice, gay people needed to repent and turn to Christ…all of the things that I think a lot of us have heard. I was very much a “goody two-shoes,” conservative with a Bible in my backpack, ready to witness to anybody who would listen. I didn’t realize at the time how annoying this was.
[laughter]
But, I mean, that was me. My identity was completely wrapped up in my faith, and…well, I mean it still is—I don’t mean to suggest in anyway that I have walked away from my faith; I would say it’s stronger. But that was my background. I only listened to Christian music, only watched TV shows and movies that my church would have approved of, and was very active in my youth group: all the things that a good Southern Baptist does.
The big secret, which I told myself I would take to my grave, was that from the moment I hit puberty and became sexually aware, my attractions were exclusively for guys. Early on in my development, I wrote it off as a phase. I heard James Dobson say that some children go through a period of sexual confusion during adolescence, so I considered it something that I would grow out of. But in the meantime I just couldn’t tell anybody because I knew they would think I was weird or sick. So I focused on God and my studies and didn’t worry about it too much.
As I got older, I became more and more aware—and painfully so—that something was different about me, compared to all the other guys that I knew. Those guys would talk about women in a way that I didn’t feel. And at first I thought that the reason I didn’t think about the opposite sex in that way was because I was such a good Christian, therefore I had no reason to objectify women!
[laughter]
It’s funny, because I’ve talked to a lot of other guys who had been through the same thing, who felt the same way… and we all kind of thought: “well, we’re good Christian boys and that’s why we don’t lust!” Eventually, though, I began to think, “Okay, something is WRONG with me.” It got to the point where I was crying myself to sleep at night, begging God “Please don’t let me feel this anymore,” because I felt dirty, I felt sick. I didn’t want to be attracted to the same gender; I wanted to be attracted to women. I considered myself straight even then—I dated women in high school.
I felt worse and worse about myself, and I felt that I had this horrible secret, which if anybody found out, they would hate me. In spite of my years of desperate prayers to take away these feelings, it never happened. I gradually began realizing that this wasn’t a phase—that it wouldn’t go away. It wasn’t until I was 18, a senior in high school, that I started making a connection between those things, and the word “gay.” I think a lot of people are shocked that it took me that long to make that connection, but the word “gay” had nothing to do with me. It had something to do with videos of half-naked men, rainbow feathered boas, and dancing in pride parades… that was gay, and I didn’t have anything to do with that: I was a good Southern Baptist kid.
So I looked into ex-gay ministries that claimed, “with prayer and therapy, you can become straight,” and I discovered that they weren’t for real. That the claims they made weren’t reality, and that even the leaders of these groups were still as attracted to the same gender as I was—even if they were married to a member of the opposite sex. And I thought, “Well I can’t do that to somebody. I can’t marry someone who I don’t feel this way about.” That started a process in college of wrestling with my faith and my sexuality. I went through a tremendous amount of depression. Eventually, I made gay friends in school, but I was also involved in Christian groups. My Christian friends didn’t understand “the gay thing” and my gay friends didn’t understand “the Christian thing.” I felt, at that time, like the only guy in the world dealing with these things.
In the process of writing my thoughts and experiences and publishing them on a personal home page, I started getting emails from people I’d never met—from all over the world—who were going through the same thing, and had no one to talk to. They were scared, and asked me for answers I didn’t have. So God started working on my heart, and as I studied what the Bible had to say, and coming to conclusions about it, I realized that I needed to do more than simply work this out for myself. I needed to make a difference for all these other people who were going through similar things.
In August 2001, after I graduated, I created this online community, called the Gay Christian Network. Originally, it began as a support group for others. I envisioned a couple dozen of us, being there for one another. Over eight years, that couple dozen became thirteen, or maybe fourteen, thousand. It’s also become a non-profit organization focused on, not just supporting gay Christians, but trying to help straight Christians understand the issues, to facilitate parents or family members who might wrestle with a loved one being gay—all the things associated with that. We do a lot of things: an annual conference, online communities, local groups, our documentary video, and so on.
JW: Nate, tell me how you got involved with this. What’s your story?
Nate Krogh: I found GCN during a senior year during college. I actually came out to my family at the beginning of that Fall semester, found the Network, and felt greatly blessed by the staff – their services, ministries, etc.
Initially, my family wasn’t receptive to [my sexuality]. When I came out, it was a shock to them. I know now, but at the time I did not—as it took me years to come to terms with my sexual orientation, and how that interacted with my faith–it was going to take my family time as well. The biggest thing was that they saw I still desired to have faith as a foundational aspect of my life. So, by seeing me get involved with, and immediately rush to, a Christian organization for support confused them; it didn’t mesh with how they understood the behaviors of LGBT peoples.
After several months of processing things, I felt like I was at a place where I could, and wanted to, give back. So I asked Justin, “What can I do to help? I’d like to do something,” while volunteering as a message board administrator for the site over the course of those months. As I got their support, became more involved in the community, etc., it has slowly started turning things around. Granted, my family would be more of the “Side B” theological standpoint, but it’s leaps and bounds from where they were before.
Eventually, a job posting came up for the Office Manager position in Raleigh, North Carolina. My friends talked me into it, said basically, “What do you have to lose?” A few weeks later, I made the move, and here I am.
Tags: gay christian network, Homosexuality, Interview, justin lee, nate krogh, Tony Campolo


9 Comments
Thanks for this interview. I’m now interested in checking out the gcn website and learning more about the two (Side A/Side B) perspectives. As a traditionally-raised, straight evangelical, I haven’t gotten much exposure to gay Christian perspectives and am grateful for this opportunity to become more educated on the subject. Thanks, Burnside, for all the exposure to such varied Christian perspectives. And thanks to Justin and Nate for your courage and honesty in this ministry. Blessings.
Thanks, Kathleen, for your willingness to learn and understand…about sexual orientation…about scripture interpretation…about Gay Christians! “Out” or “in the closet,” we are EVERYWHERE – AND WE LOVE JESUS PASSIONATELY! Blessings to you, sister!!!
Kathleen:
Justin and Nate are two of my heroes. I absolutely love these guys to death; not known them very long, and it’s cool to meet people so courageous.
John
John,
Great interview, man. Some great stuff to think about. The issue is so complex, even if you believe the Bible clearly states that homosexuality is a sin, which I do. That doesn’t make the application of that any more simple, and my heart goes out to people who are struggling with this. I love the heart for Christ that clearly comes through here, though, and the work they’re doing is important.
John,
Agreed… those that are “struggling” are the ones MOST hurt by the Church. But in the words of a famous preacher… “The Christian Army is the ONLY Army that kills its wounded!”
Thanks for this, as someone who recently has found herself surrounded by a network of close gay friends, it’s great to have resources for me to use to better understand them. The GCN site, their documentary, and Andrew Marin’s book, “Love is an Orientation” are all great places to start for anyone struggling to understand how someone can claim to be “gay” and “Christian.”
Thank you for this wonderful article. GCN is an amazing community and truly reflects God’s heart for all people. Should the church as a whole love the same way GCN does, we would all be in a much better place. Thank you Justin and Nate. Look forward to seeing you both in TN!
I think this issue will confuse me until the day I die. My mother left my dad when I was five years old for another woman. She said she was young when she had us kids and didn’t know then that she was lesbian. She dated several woman after that and eventually fall in love with and lived with a woman for 10 years. Then the Holy Spirit convicted her of her lifestyle. She repented – it wasn’t easy because her gay and lesbian friends tried to tell her it was ok with God. But she felt a deep conviction – so she repented and became born-again, left the woman she was living with, and underwent some therapy. She eventually met a man, fall in love, and married him.
My mom use to tell me she was born lesbian and couldn’t do anything about it. Now she says her eyes are open and she was deceived. She enjoys a wonderful relationship with God now.
So why do people say change is not possible? And why would the Holy Spirit convict my mom and not others in the same manner? And if same-sex couples are ok in the eyes of God, do they have to adhere to the same principles as opposite-sex couples (no sex before marriage, etc)?
Like I said, this will always confuse me. I am grateful for my mom’s experience for two reasons. One – I lived with her and her wife for awhile and saw that they were a normal couple (there are some strange ideas floating around what it is like in a same-sex couple household). And two – because I have seen the power of the Holy Spirit to change just about anything.
God Bless us all as we try to figure this out!
A thought-provoking interview. Perhaps it’s time for Christianity to embrace an authentic and workable ideal for all people: being as celibate as possible outside of loving, monogamous relationships — most especially marriage.
If 15% of Christian males and 5% of Christian women are gay, lesbian, or bisexual, this would be 200 million Christians. It makes no sense to run them all out of church nor to assume they are all going to Hell.
On the other hand, tolerating promiscuity and open relationships and things like that makes no sense either. All Christians, no matter what their orientation, should be encouraged toward the ideal of monogamous love. It is those who don’t believe in that ideal who are not truly Christians.
One thing more: as many as 40% of males experiment with gay sex before marriage and then move on. The Church has a vital duty to them as well, to ensure they stay on the path to a good, loving, and monogamous heterosexual marriage. If the Church simply embraces homosexuality, it might help lead many of them astray.
I respect Justin’s point about gay guys who get married to women. This kind of deception seems to me to be very un-Christian, even evil. As straight Christians treat gay and lesbian Christians with dignity and include them in a body of Christ, affirming their relationships — this seems like the better road than the road Christianity has been on in the past.
Seems like Justin Lee has worked out a lot of important issues, and is providing a great service for as many as 200 million Christians who may need it. Seems like a brother in Christ to me, and a good Christian leader.